Disclosure: Tried and Kept is reader-supported. If you buy through links on this site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never changes what we recommend. Read our full disclosure.
Last checked: 23 October 2026. This guide is research-based: it draws on official specifications and manuals from Baratza and Breville, owner reviews and long-term owner reports. We haven’t run our own hands-on tests of these grinders.
If you’ve read our Bambino Plus vs Barista Express comparison, you’ll know the most important thing about a machine without a built-in grinder: the grinder you pair with it matters as much as the machine itself. For many first-time home baristas, the choice comes down to two grinders at the same price, the Baratza Encore ESP and the Breville Smart Grinder Pro.
Both list at $199.95 in the US, both use 40 mm conical burrs, and both are widely recommended as beginner espresso grinders. But they take very different approaches. The Encore ESP is a simple, mechanical, espresso-focused grinder built around repairability. The Smart Grinder Pro is a feature-rich digital grinder with timed dosing and a portafilter holder. Here’s how to choose the one you’re more likely to keep.
Quick answer
- Choose the Baratza Encore ESP if espresso is your main drink, you want fine control in the espresso range, and you value easy cleaning and long-term repairability.
- Choose the Breville Smart Grinder Pro if you want timed, programmable dosing, prefer grinding straight into the portafilter, and like having a big bean hopper and an LCD screen.
Encore ESP vs Smart Grinder Pro: specs side by side
| Feature | Baratza Encore ESP | Breville Smart Grinder Pro (BCG820) |
|---|---|---|
| US list price (official sites, Oct 2026) | $199.95 | $199.95 |
| Burrs | 40 mm hardened alloy steel conical burrs | Hardened stainless steel conical burrs |
| Grind settings | 40 steps: #1–20 fine “micro” steps for espresso, #21–40 larger steps for filter | 60 settings: #1–30 for espresso, 31–60 for drip, percolator and French press |
| Adjustment | Twist the hopper | Grind size dial |
| Dosing | Manual: pulse button or on/off switch | Digital timer (“Dosing iQ”), adjustable in 0.2-second steps; program by shots or cups |
| Grinds into | Included 54 mm dosing cup (with 58 mm adapter) | Portafilter (50–54 mm and 58 mm cradles included) or grinds container |
| Display | None | Backlit LCD (setting, time, shots/cups) |
| Bean hopper | Removable hopper | 1 lb hopper with locking system |
| Burr speed | About 550 rpm (per retailer listing), geared for lower noise and heat | Not specified by Breville |
| Cleaning | Tool-free quick-release cone burr | Removable upper burr; cleaning brush included |
| Dimensions | Not listed on Baratza’s sales sheet | 8.5 x 6.3 x 15.3 in (W x D x H) |
| Warranty | 1-year manufacturer warranty (Baratza sales sheet) | Check Breville’s site for your region |
Specs from Baratza’s and Breville’s official product pages, Baratza’s Encore ESP sales sheet and the Smart Grinder Pro instruction manual. Prices change often, so check current prices before you buy.
The key difference: how the settings are spread out
At first glance, 60 settings sounds better than 40. But the number of steps that falls in the espresso range, and how far apart they are, matters more than the total.
Espresso needs very small changes in grind size. Going one step finer can turn a fast, sour shot into a slow, bitter one. That’s why Baratza redesigned the classic Encore into the ESP with what it calls a “dual-range adjustment system.” Settings 1 to 20 are micro-steps aimed at espresso, while 21 to 40 are bigger macro-steps for filter coffee. In other words, half the dial is devoted to fine-tuning espresso.
The Smart Grinder Pro spreads 60 settings across all brew methods. According to Breville’s manual, settings 1 to 30 are for espresso, 31 to 48 for drip, 49 to 54 for percolator and 55 to 60 for French press. That still gives you 30 espresso settings, and its upper burr can be adjusted to shift the range finer if needed. Owners often mention doing this to get a finer grind for single-wall baskets.
Both approaches work. The ESP is built to make espresso dialing simple, while the Smart Grinder Pro aims to be an all-rounder.
Dosing and workflow
This is where the two grinders feel most different in daily use.
Breville Smart Grinder Pro: timed and hands-free
The Smart Grinder Pro uses a digital timer. You pick the number of shots or cups, and the grinder runs for a set time. You can fine-tune that time in 0.2-second steps and save it. It comes with two portafilter cradles, one for 50–54 mm portafilters (which includes Breville’s own 54 mm machines like the Bambino Plus) and one for 58 mm, so you can push the portafilter in and grind straight into it.
Owners like this convenience, especially for quick mornings. The catch is that timed dosing is never perfectly exact. Bean density and roast vary, so many owners still weigh their dose on a small scale for consistency.
Baratza Encore ESP: simple and manual
The Encore ESP has no timer. You grind using the front pulse button or the on/off switch into the included 54 mm dosing cup, then tip the grounds into your portafilter. Baratza says the dosing cup is anti-static and comes with a 58 mm adapter and a tray that holds it at the right distance from the chute.
This is a “weigh your beans first” workflow, sometimes called single dosing. You weigh out 18 g of beans, grind them all and transfer them. It’s an extra step, but it gives you a consistent dose and keeps beans fresh in a sealed container instead of sitting in the hopper.
Noise, heat and static
Williams Sonoma’s listing for the Encore ESP says its burrs turn at about 550 rpm, driven by a high-torque motor through a speed-reducing gearbox. Slower burrs generally mean less noise and less heat, and the listing claims less static as well.
Breville doesn’t publish burr speed for the Smart Grinder Pro. Its manual mentions a grinding chamber designed to reduce static and an automatic thermal cut-out that protects the motor. Owner reports on both grinders mention some static and mess, which is common with grinders at this price. A few drops of water on the beans before grinding is a popular owner trick to cut static. Check that your grinder’s manual doesn’t advise against it.
Cleaning and long-term repairability
Since our whole site is about gear people keep, this section matters a lot.
Baratza built its reputation on repairability. The Encore ESP’s cone burr, burr holder and hopper come out without tools, which makes cleaning much easier. Baratza also sells replacement parts for its grinders, and long-term owners often say they’ve kept an Encore running for years by replacing a worn burr or gearbox part rather than the whole grinder.
The Smart Grinder Pro’s upper burr is removable for cleaning, and Breville includes a cleaning brush. Owner reports suggest it holds up well for many people, though it has more electronics, such as the LCD and timer board, which add more things that could fail over time. Availability of replacement parts varies by region.
Baratza warns against washing the burrs with water because they will rust. Use a brush or grinder-cleaning tablets instead.
Pros and cons
Baratza Encore ESP
- Pros: 20 fine micro-steps dedicated to espresso; simple, sturdy controls; tool-free burr removal; strong reputation for repairs and spare parts; dosing cup suits single dosing.
- Cons: no timer or display; you’ll need a scale for consistent doses; extra step to transfer grounds into the portafilter; larger filter steps are less fine-tunable for pour-over enthusiasts.
Breville Smart Grinder Pro
- Pros: programmable timed dosing; grinds directly into the portafilter; 1 lb hopper and grinds container; covers espresso to French press; adjustable upper burr.
- Cons: timed doses still drift with different beans; more electronics to go wrong; owners often need to adjust the upper burr for fine espresso; grounds can clump or spray around the portafilter.
Buying criteria: what to check before you choose
- What you drink most. If it’s almost all espresso and milk drinks, the Encore ESP’s espresso-first design is a natural fit. If you switch between espresso, drip and French press, the Smart Grinder Pro’s spread of settings is handy.
- Your portafilter size. Breville home machines typically use 54 mm portafilters, while many other brands use 58 mm. The Smart Grinder Pro includes cradles for both, and the Encore ESP includes a 54 mm dosing cup with a 58 mm adapter.
- Your workflow. Do you want to press a button and walk away, or are you happy to weigh and transfer? Be honest here, because it’s the part you’ll repeat every day.
- Scale or no scale. Either way, a small kitchen scale that reads to 0.1 g is one of the best upgrades for espresso. Factor it into your budget.
- Repairs and support. If you want a grinder that can be fixed rather than replaced, check parts availability for your country before buying.
- Counter and cabinet space. The Smart Grinder Pro stands 15.3 inches tall, according to Breville, so measure under your wall cabinets.
Which one should you keep?
For an espresso-first home setup, especially paired with a machine like the Bambino Plus, the Encore ESP’s dedicated espresso range and repairable design make it the choice owners seem to stick with longest. For mixed brewing and maximum convenience, the Smart Grinder Pro is a well-proven all-rounder that does everything reasonably well at the same price.
If you’re still deciding on a machine, our Bambino Plus vs Barista Express guide explains when a built-in grinder makes more sense. You can also read more about how we research products on our How We Review page.
FAQ
Is the Baratza Encore ESP good enough for espresso?
Yes. Baratza designed it specifically for espresso, with 20 micro-step settings for fine adjustment. It’s a beginner to intermediate grinder, so very demanding light-roast espresso drinkers may eventually want a higher-end model.
Does the Smart Grinder Pro work with the Bambino Plus?
Yes. The Bambino Plus uses a 54 mm portafilter, and the Smart Grinder Pro includes a 50–54 mm cradle for grinding straight into it.
Can I use the Encore ESP for pour-over or French press?
Yes. Settings 21 to 40 are designed for filter and immersion brewing. Those steps are larger, so you get less fine control than in the espresso range.
Why does my grinder need adjusting when I change beans?
Different beans and roast levels need different grind sizes for the same shot time. Small adjustments with every new bag are normal.
Should I wash my grinder burrs?
No. Baratza warns that washing burrs with water will make them rust. Use a brush or grinder-cleaning tablets instead.
Do I need a scale?
It’s strongly recommended for both. Even with the Smart Grinder Pro’s timer, weighing your dose is the easiest way to get consistent shots.
Sources
- Baratza, Encore ESP product page
- Baratza, Encore ESP sales sheet (adjustment system, burrs, dosing cup, warranty)
- Williams Sonoma, Baratza Encore ESP listing (burr speed and cleaning notes)
- Breville, Smart Grinder Pro product page
- Breville, Smart Grinder Pro instruction manual
- Owner reviews on retailer sites and long-term owner discussions in home espresso communities
Surendar Kumar